For Reviwers - Production Enginnering Archives

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur ad elit.
Morbi tincidunt libero ac ante accumsan.
Go to content
Review procedure

Papers which are submitted for a review should be in accordance with the publication preparation guideline provided in "For Authors".
Papers which are submitted to the executive editor shall be assessed by two independent reviewers (double blind reviews). The Editorial Board chooses reviewers, following the themes presented in the paper.
The reviewer is independent from the author of the reviewed work and there is no the conflict of interest. A review has writing form and ends with an explicit request for admission the paper to publish or the reject. The review procedure is done with confidentially.
The reviewing form is located in the "Review system" (after receiving the login and password). If the reviewer has problems with the online review system, you can use the review form and send it back to the editors' address.
Manuscript’s qualification / rejection criteria.
The reviewers have two weeks to perform the review from the moment they agree to the review.

A review form (online, login required) is available on the website of the journal. The review must end with an unambiguous conclusion of the Reviewer regarding the to the approval of the article for publication or its rejection. The reviewer can specify in the review form whether the article should be:
  • published without revision,
  • published with minor revision,
  • published with major revision,
  • re-reviewed again after revision,
  • rejected.

If there is a need of revision, the author(s) is obliged to correct the text, introduce additions and changes required by the Reviewers. After the revision, the Editors decide about manuscript’s publication.
If the Reviewer in the review form indicated that the manuscript after the revision should be re-review, the manuscript after authors’ correction is again subjected to the review process by the same Reviewers.
In the case of one negative review, the Editors choose a third Reviewer. In the case of two negative reviews, the manuscript is rejected.

If the reviewer has problems  with the online review system, you can use the review form and send it  back to the editors' address.
link to the review form: Word.docx
Back to content